If a new product you would like to market is not
patented, consider the merits of commercializing as a
trade secret.
There are many products introduced into the marketplace
that have not been patented, but are protected as a trade
secret -- Coke-Cola being a well-known example. There can
be distinct advantages to this approach where the
manufacturer does not wish to reveal through patent
application the details engineered into his or her
product's technology or its formulation. Comparative
Example -- Hypothetical Homeland
Security Device.
Immediately following the September 11, 2001 attack on
the U.S., the Bush administration emphasis was on
protecting Americans from other possible follow-up
terrorist attacks -- particularly 'something from the air.'
In retrospect, we now realize that there is much more to
worry about than just sealing our windows and door with
plastic and duct tape -- we have to worry even more about
maritime
cargo coming into our ports, unscreened
aviation cargo, and the like!
However, although there continue to be jokes on late-night
television about Homeland Security's duct
tape campaign, it still represents one
security problem needing a solution. So, for the purpose
of illustration, we have addressed this particular area
as a Homeland Security example.
Maybe you don't like duct tape, but let us say you have
devised an adjustable frame stretched with an integral
"accordion-folded" plastic sheet that can be
pre-fitted to cover the inside of a home's windows and/or
doors to 'seal' in case of a biological or chemical
attack. To illustrate, the frame and covering would
probably be patented (not a
trade secret) since it could be easily reverse
engineered.
But suppose the success of the device lies in a wall-clinging
boarder strip feature (to seal all around the edge) that
uses electro-static principles (i.e., to
replace duct tape).
There are various possibilities that come to mind for
implementing this feature including a specially
formulated substance (like kitchen 'cling wraps' but
stronger clinging). Assuming the formulation is not
easily reverse engineered, this serves as a
perfect example of a candidate for marketing as a
trade secret.
Our group is knowledgeable in the international
trade laws that govern the treatment of trade secrets and
has experience in international marketing of such
products. We can help you evaluate existing and future
competition, estimate potential and consequences for
"reverse engineering" of the product, handle
details on trademarks and needs for regulatory approvals
and Federal and State licensing. The Federal Department
of Homeland Security is already playing an important role
in brokering new and better ideas to make America safer.
A product we helped move to the commercial market.
Eight years ago our group, Bartley
Technologies Incorporated , began to
explore an experimental product that was being developed
for the management of fungal vascular diseases that
continue to threaten plants and trees in many parts of
the world including large regions of North America and
Europe. Interventions to the advance of these types of
fungal diseases had been limited to digging seven-foot-deep
trenches, where possible, to interrupt transmission of
the disease through root structures, and limiting tree
pruning to discourage transmission via vectors. Texas
A&M also recommended periodic use of "chemotherapy"
root-flair injection with a toxic anti-fungal chemical.
However, it had long been recognized that
trees and certain other plants have their own natural
mechanisms for
fighting such disease.
The idea now was to engineer a product that could enhance
the important processes in a plant's root structure and
effectiveness of a plant's own immune systems. After more
than a decade of research, development and testing, this
new methodology yielded a unique new non-toxic water-soluble
product that can be applied to the underside of the
leaves and on the ground beneath the tree or plant. In
some cases, injection of the product may be a viable
option. Although total understanding of chemical and
biologic mechanisms of this product still does
not exist, we were able to gain enough experience working
with the product to conclude that it pointed to a new integrated
approach to saving endangered trees and plants.
The design of the product -- which the manufacturer
determined to be a trade secret -- encompassed
plant tolerance, modification of nutritional status,
amplification of natural plant responses to both microbes
and insects, root health maintenance (due to root hormone
production and nutrient uptake efficiency) and insect
management (biological and conventional). As part of our
feasibility study of this 'New New Product,' our
firm explored many dimensions related to its
marketability and long-term efficacy. Tests, including
those conducted by our firm, showed that regular periodic
treatments using this new product increased the number of
survivors of the fungal disease. Measurement of success,
of course, must be based on sound epidemiology. We
concluded that complementary interventions to vascular
diseases such as trenching, where feasible, should also
be continued. But, most importantly, we discovered that
the nutrients/biostimulants contained in this product
seem to benefit all plants and trees.
Satisfied with our due-diligence, we were able to
negotiate exclusive world-wide rights to distribute the
product above and trademark it. We then contributed to
the creation of a new company that would be the sole
distributor of this and some related products. We located
the new company initially just outside Austin, TX, in the
Texas Hill Country, home of the newest and hottest
'Silicon Valley' of cutting-edge companies now developing
around the US. We sold the company several years ago, and
the new owner is marketing the product nationally.
If you would like more information on new products
we have developed or are looking at, e-mail us at our HOT E-mail address: bartleytech_@_yahoo.com
[PLEASE
BACK OUT UNDERSCORES BOTH SIDES OF @ PLACED TO AVOID
SPAMMING -- THANK YOU]
For more information on
an idea for a 'New New Thing" more
likely patented,
Click
On Innovative Products FAQs
|